I know, I know—Key West isn’t exactly the first place that pops into your head when someone says “sushi restaurant.” You’re probably thinking key lime pie, conch fritters, or some fresh seafood with a mojito in hand while live music plays somewhere in the background.
But trust me on this one: the sushi in Key West? It’s underrated and totally worth the hype. Maybe it’s the ocean breeze or the Duval Street energy, but sushi just hits differently here. If you’re planning your first time to the island or looking to find a new favorite, I’ve got you.
Here are 5 sushi spots that bring the flavor, the vibe, and yes—the wasabi.
1. MisoHappy
504 Southard Street, Key West, FL
Don’t let the cozy (read: tiny) space fool you—MisoHappy is a powerhouse. They serve good sushi, hearty Thai food, and a big dose of friendly staff energy. You’ve gotta try the Love Key West Roll: fried lobster tempura, asparagus, scallions, topped with avocado, spicy mayo, eel sauce and yum yum sauce. It’s basically the lobster roll’s cool cousin who parties on Duval.
If you’re a ramen lover, they’ve got some soul-warming broths too. Bonus: it’s perfect for date night without the fuss.
2. Origami Sushi Bar
1075 Duval Street (Corner of Virginia & Duval)
Established in 1995, this local favorite has a garden patio that’s peaceful and lush—basically the perfect place to unwind with a rainbow roll and a glass of sake. Origami has mastered the art of traditional Japanese cuisine with a Florida Keys twist.
Try the beef tataki, the comforting udon noodle soup, or anything with spicy tuna. The ambiance is great for a casual dinner, or a fancy-ish Key West walking tour detour for your taste buds.
3. Sushi Song
925 Duval Street
A late-night gem! Sushi Song serves up some of the freshest sushi on the island, and they’re open until 4 a.m. (yes, really). If you’ve been hopping bars and drag queen shows along Duval, this is your “wrap the night with a rainbow roll” stop.
The vibe is chill-meets-chic, and you’ll find a blend of classic and adventurous options. Think: Ahi AIA roll, crunchy spicy tuna, and all the quality service you want at 2 a.m.
4. Bangkok Happy Bowl Thai Bistro & Sushi Bar
927 Duval Street
Serving up the best Thai food and good sushi, this place checks all the boxes. It’s an elevated Asian dining experience that doesn’t skimp on the flavor. Whether you’re craving pad Thai, a sushi roll, or both, you’ll get great food with a side of island zen.
Hot tip: try the mango roll if it’s on the specials. And yes, happy hour here is worth showing up early for.
5. Thai Island Restaurant & Sushi Bar
711 Eisenhower Drive (Garrison Bight Marina)
Looking for a side of ocean views with your sushi? Thai Island is located right on the marina and has outdoor seating that makes you feel like you’re on vacation… because, well, you are.
They do great combo plates, Bento Boxes, and sushi rolls. The portions are generous, the vibe is laid-back, and it’s the kind of place where you might accidentally spend your whole afternoon sipping sake. Also a great pre- or post-charter boat bite.
Bonus Mention: Benihana
3591 S Roosevelt Blvd
Sure, it’s a national chain, but sometimes you just want filet mignon, a shrimp toss, and a show. It’s part hibachi, part theater, and always a fun stop if you’re with a group or entertaining out-of-towners. Plus, there’s something nostalgic about a sizzling table-side performance.
So… did your favorite sushi spot make the list?
If not, let me know! I’m always on the lookout for the next best sushi restaurant in Key West FL, and I’d love to hear your picks. Whether it’s for a casual lunch, date night, or a post-Key West walking tour snack, these sushi places deliver.
Craving sushi yet? Go plan your great time in paradise.
And hey—don’t forget to grab some key lime pie for dessert. This is Key West, after all.
Want more tasty picks, local tips, and updates on all things Key West?
Sign up for the Fun in Key West newsletter
Because food tastes better when you’re in the know.
