Best Cuban Coffee in Key West – The Ultimate Guide

Looking for the best Cuban coffee in Key West? Well, buckle up, caffeine lovers, because we’re taking a flavorful tour through the Conch Republic’s Cuban coffee scene. Whether it’s your first experience sipping a café con leche, or you’re a seasoned aficionado scouting out the hidden gems, I’ve got all the coffee hot spots covered. Spoiler alert—this post pairs well with Cuban bread and maybe a guava pastry.

Grab your coffee mug (or colada cup). Here’s everything you need to know to caffeinate your way through Key West’s Cuban culture.

What Makes Cuban Coffee Special?

Cuban coffee isn’t just a drink; it’s an experience. From its bold flavors to the warm embrace of Key West’s Cuban heritage, each cup tells a story. Unlike its Italian counterpart (Italian espresso fans, don’t come for me!), Cuban coffee is sweetened during the brewing process, creating a distinct, frothy caramel layer on top. That delectable layer is called “espumita,” and trust me, it’s worth the hype.

Types of Cuban Coffee You Should Try

Before we jump into the best places to grab a cup, here’s a quick coffee cheat sheet to save you a blank stare at the counter.

  1. Cuban Espresso (Cafecito)

A small but mighty cup packed with bold, sweet flavor and topped with that signature espumita.

  1. Colada

A large cup of Cuban espresso (basically a cafecito party pack). It’s served with a few tiny demitasse cups because Cuban culture loves sharing, and one colada is enough to caffeinate your entire squad.

  1. Café con Leche

Think of this as a sweet and creamy latte. Smooth Cuban espresso meets steamed milk—and seriously, it’s perfect with Cuban toast.

  1. Iced Café con Leche

Same dreamy café con leche vibes, but iced. Pro tip: Add a splash of sweetened condensed milk for extra flavor.

  1. Buchito (Bucci)

A double shot of robust Cuban espresso. This one’s for you if you’re riding solo and need a punch of energy!

Best Cuban Coffee Spots in Key West

1. Cuban Coffee Queen

Arguably the most iconic of the Key West coffee shops, Cuban Coffee Queen is a must-visit. Start your day with a café con leche and grab a selfie in front of their original location mural near the Key West Historic Seaport. They also offer a second location near Duval Street, which is the perfect spot to refuel after some sightseeing. Bonus points? They serve great Cuban bread and the best Cuban sandwiches this side of Havana.

2. Sandy’s Café

This hidden gem on White Street is beloved by locals. It’s connected to M&M Laundry, but trust me, its charm and great prices make it worth a visit. Order a colada to share or pair a café con leche with their hearty allure of Cuban sandwiches, loaded with mojo pork and Swiss cheese on perfectly toasted bread.

3. Baby’s Coffee

Located a bit outside of downtown Key West, this local favorite is known for its great coffee and chill vibe. Perfect for coffee lovers looking to escape the hustle and bustle. Don’t forget to pick up one of their breakfast burritos as an added bonus.

4. Glazed Donuts

For those with a sweet tooth, Glazed Donuts serves up freshly baked donuts and authentic Cuban coffee. Pair your iced café con leche with their unique donut offerings—because why not treat yourself?

5. Five Brothers Grocery and Sandwich Shop

This family-owned sandwich shop is steeped in tradition and Cuban flavors. Their great sandwiches perfectly complement a strong café cubano. Plus, the cozy vibe makes it feel like you’ve discovered a hidden gem.

6. Anna’s Café

Located on the southernmost end of Duval Street, Anna’s is another perfect spot to learn the ropes of ordering Cuban coffee. Check out their handy wall cheat sheet, so you can order your cafelito or colada like a pro.

Why Cuban Coffee Is a Key Wester’s Must-Try

Beyond the bold, robust zest of the cafecito, enjoying a cup of Cuban coffee is an instant cultural getaway. Coffee here isn’t just a beverage—it’s a ritual, a connection to loved ones, and an excuse to slow down amidst the tranquility of island life.

Pair your drink with Cuban toast or a Cuban mix sandwich, garnished with buttery Cuban bread, to savor the Cuban heartbeat of Key West.

Pro tip? Many coffee shops also double as great breakfast spots. If you find yourself near the Key West Historic Seaport, you’ll likely stumble into a local artists’ enclave or live music for an added splash of charm.

How to Order Like a Pro

Cuban coffee menus can be intimidating with so many choices. But don’t sweat it—Key West locals are all about welcoming vibes. And most shops are happy to explain the difference between a double bucci and an authentic café cubano.

If you’re not sure what to try first, here’s my ultimate starter combo for Cuban coffee rookies (you can thank me later):

  • Café con leche with two sugars
  • Pair it with buttered Cuban bread or a guava pastry

You won’t regret it.

Next Time You Visit Key West

Whether you’re on Duval Street enjoying a perfect spot for people-watching, catching a ferry to the Dry Tortugas, or exploring the heart of Old Town, make Cuban coffee your first stop in Key West.

The blend of bold, sweet flavor, great food, and a sense of cultural tradition will set the tone for your entire trip. Did I miss one of your favorite places? Tell me what I should try next time.

Need Even More Key West Foodie Adventures?

Check out more of our insider tips on the best coffee shops, delicious sandwich spots, and where to find great food and drinks in the Conch Republic.

Related Posts