These Will Delight Your Taste Buds
When you think of the Florida Keys, what comes to mind first? Tiki bars, crystal-clear waters, and fresh seafood, right? But what about Italian food? Stick with me because Key West is not only about tropical cocktails and fresh lobster tails. This little island paradise is also packed with bellissimo Italian eateries serving everything from authentic Italian cuisine to some of the freshest homemade pasta you’ve ever twirled on a fork.
Whether you’re here for the first time or a seasoned visitor, this list of Key West’s best Italian restaurants will bring a whole new flavor to your tropical getaway. From cozy and casual to upscale fine dining, these spots have something for every mood and occasion.
1. Bruschetta Francesca
For a slice of Sicily right in the heart of Key West, look no further than Bruschetta Francesca. The chef, originally from Palermo, brings mamma’s recipes straight from Italy to your plate. Think marinara sauce so fresh it could make even the tomatoes blush. (Okay, not literally. But you get the idea.)
This atmospheric dining spot offers casual vibes with a touch of a sophisticated side, making it perfect for laid-back evenings or dinner with large parties. Close your eyes, take a bite, and you can almost feel the Sicilian sun on your face. And don’t worry about leaving hungry–their pasta portions will do the trick.
Pro Tip: Show up hungry, and don’t skip the white wine pairing.
2. La Trattoria
Welcome to Key West’s premiere Italian dining experience, where martinis and pasta take center stage. With two great locations (on Duval Street and Oceanside), La Trattoria is also the proud home of the original Martini Monday. Yes, you read that right. Think $7 martinis from their original martini list that will have you rethinking how you start your week.
Their classic Italian menu is a carb lover’s dream, offering an array of pasta selections alongside a killer wine list. Whether you’re in the mood for happy hour or a nice dinner, this is the spot that screams, “Treat yourself!”
Pro Tip: Come for the martinis, stay for the dining experience.
3. Mangia Mangia
When the restaurant name literally translates to “Eat, eat,” you know you’re in for a good time. Mangia Mangia serves fresh homemade pasta that’s locally loved and universally praised. Their rich marinara sauce, made with the freshest ingredients, will take your taste buds on a whirlwind culinary adventure.
Mangia Mangia keeps things cozy, casual, and delicious. They’re all about authentic Italian food served family-style, so bring your crew along or be prepared to take leftovers back to your hotel!
Pro Tip: This is the locals’ pick. If the people who live here love it, you know it’s one of the best restaurants in town.
4. New York Pasta Garden
This is where New York’s Italian vibe meets Florida Keys charm. Tucked away in an Old Town garden, New York Pasta Garden combines hearty portions, an exceptional wine list, and an equally exceptional menu. It’s easy to see why this spot lands on so many “must-visit” lists, including a shoutout in the New York Times.
Perfect for first-time visitors and returning fans alike, this restaurant captures authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Key West.
Pro Tip: Try their fresh takes on classic Italian dishes. Don’t miss out on the vibrant atmosphere in their green, tucked-away garden.
5. Bel Mare
Located at the A&B Marina, Bel Mare (Italian for “beautiful sea”) offers some of the finest Italian dining experiences in Key West. Bring out your dressiest resort wear because this spot has all the elevated vibes for a romantic dinner or celebration meal.
Pair your dish with one of their expertly curated white wines or red wines, and your dinner will feel less like a meal and more like an event. Make sure to snap a photo with the marina view—we’re betting this will end up on your TikTok “vacay photo dump.”
Pro Tip: Book a table in advance; it’s worth the extra planning!
6. Antonia’s
If you’re walking along Duval Street, Antonia’s is that classic Italian spot that might catch your eye—but head on inside, and you’ll be rewarded with much more than a passing glance. Known for its fresh, homemade pasta and incredible menu offerings, Antonia’s has been a staple of the Key West dining scene for decades.
What sets this spot apart is its perfect balance of sophistication and comfort. You can savor a decadent meal in a welcoming and unpretentious atmosphere.
Pro Tip: This is the perfect spot to slow down and savor every bite. Trust us, you’ll want to.
Check out our Fun in Key West Book Club! Click here
7. Abbondanza Italian Restaurant
Head to Abbondanza Key West for a winning combination of cozy and authentic Italian dining. This spot, nestled into three atmospheric cigar maker cottages, offers a dining experience that balances laid-back vibes and Italian elegance.
Known for receiving a “People’s Choice Award,” the team’s focus is clear–on flavor, quality, and creating spaces for larger parties to enjoy an intimate dinner. Their marinara sauce is packed with bold, vibrant flavors, and the portions are generous.
Pro Tip: Perfect for group dinners and celebrations. Ask for their fresh mozzarella to start your meal on the right note!
8. Roostica
A little off the beaten path over on Stock Island, Roostica is known for its wood-fired Neapolitan pizza and, wait for it, Italian soul food. Yes, Italian soul food exists. And yes, it’s every bit as comforting and heartwarming as it sounds.
Everything here is homemade, from their signature marinara dishes to their mozzarella. This is where rustic charm meets indulgent carb-loading dreams.
Pro Tip: Swing by for a casual yet flavorful lunch or dinner.
Looking for more ideas on where to eat? Check out all of our suggestions – here
9. Onlywood
Neapolitan pizza lovers, this one’s for you! Onlywood is renowned for its imported pizza oven directly from Napoli (which explains why their pies taste heavenly). But hold on, their menu extends beyond pizza. They’re also serving up some of the best Italian food classics, including pasta dishes and house specialties that will keep you coming back for more.
Pro Tip: This is the spot for casual date nights or just hanging out with friends over the freshest Italian comfort food.
Let’s Eat (and Mangia Mangia)
Key West is full of surprises, and its Italian food scene is no exception. From homemade mozzarella and fresh homemade pasta to an original martini list and vibrant wine selections, the best Italian restaurants in Key West deliver an unparalleled dining experience. No matter how long you’re here in paradise, make it a point to savor the passion and flavors that these incredible hotspots bring to the table.
Buon appetite!
