(Including Hidden Gems!)

Searching for the absolute best lobster roll in Key West? Well, you’re in luck—because Key West doesn’t just do seafood, it does it right. Whether it’s drenched in butter, touched with tangy key lime juice, stuffed in a honey butter biscuit, or keeping it classy on a brioche bun, Key West is packed with lobster rolls that will blow your taste buds away.

And hey, here’s some good news—I’ve personally hunted down and taste-tested (what a tough job, right?) the best places in Key West to grab a lobster roll, so you don’t have to. From casual spots on Duval St. to hidden gems with outdoor picnic tables, here’s your go-to guide for a lobster extravaganza. 

Bonus points if you pair these incredible rolls with a slice of key lime pie or a refreshing margarita!

1. DJ’s Clam Shack  

Location: Duval Street  

Featured on Food Network’s Diner, Drive-Ins, and Dives, DJ’s Clam Shack is one of those places you simply can’t skip. Their Maine lobster roll is iconic. We’re talking about chunky Maine lobster meat, no fillers, and a perfectly toasted hot dog bun. Add a side of sweet potato fries or coleslaw, and you’ve got yourself the kind of meal dreams are made of.  

The slogan here is “Northeast meets the South,” and they deliver on that promise with their no-frills, tasty lobster rolls. Want the absolute best lobster roll on Duval St.? This might just be the one.

2. Lobster Shack Key West  

Location: South Street (near Southernmost Point)  

If you’re a fan of variety, Lobster Shack Key West has got your back. These guys serve the classic New England lobster roll, a Key lime lobster roll with a buttery kick and a hint of lime wedge, and, for the spice lovers, the fiery Diablo lobster roll (sriracha + fresh jalapeños = heaven).  

Oh, and here’s something fun—if you’re not in the mood for a roll, their grilled cheese lobster sandwich with bacon could easily be one of the best things you eat on your trip.

Pro tip? They’re only open Tuesday through Saturday, so plan wisely!  

3. Eaton Street Seafood Market  

Location: Eaton Street  

It’s not just a market; it’s a great place to grab seafood salads, fresh lobster, and even a killer cold lobster roll. Their Key West lobster roll is especially unique with its key lime mustard twist, adding a tangy zing that’ll have your taste buds doing a happy dance.

Choose a spot at their outdoor picnic tables and soak up the Key West vibes while you chow down on some of the best seafood in town.  

4. Seaside Café at the Mansion  

Location: Southernmost House  

Looking for something a little fancier? Seaside Café steps it up with their honey butter lobster biscuits—yes, you heard that right. Whether you get them hot or cold, these biscuits are pure magic.  

Pair that with oceanfront views, and you’ve got one of the most unforgettable first-time dining experiences in Key West.  

5. Blackfin Bistro  

Location: Duval Street  

Available only on their Friday to Sunday lunch menu, Blackfin Bistro’s New England-style lobster roll comes with house-made chips and the cozy charm of dining in a seafood restaurant that knows its stuff. This is a casual spot perfect for unwinding after exploring the island.

6. Latitudes  

Location: Sunset Key  

For a truly luxe experience, hop on a ferry to Sunset Key and enjoy your Maine lobster roll in style. Served on a griddled bun, this roll is elevated more by its setting—white sand beaches, swaying palm trees, and a fancy oyster bar make every bite unforgettable.

Don’t forget to dress up a bit; there’s a dress code here because, you know, you’re dining on an island paradise.

7. Ocean Grill and Bar  

Location: Duval Street  

For a mix of flavors, Ocean Grill and Bar combines Florida spiny lobster and Maine lobster tail in their roll. It’s the ultimate combo for seafood lovers who want the best of both coasts in one bite.

Need more ideas on where to eat? Check out all of our suggestions!

8. Garbo’s Grill at Hank’s Hair of the Dog Saloon  

Location: Caroline Street  

Last but certainly not least, Garbo’s Grill is an eclectic food truck tucked behind Hank’s Hair of the Dog Saloon. Their New England lobster roll hits all the right notes—fresh, flavorful, and oh-so-satisfying. Plus, you can wash it down with a glass of White Peach Sangria while enjoying some live music.  

This casual spot has all the cool Key West vibes. Grab a spot at their picnic tables and soak it all in.  

Bonus Picks for Lobster Lovers  

• Stone Crab Benedict at Blue Heaven – Not a lobster roll, but a must-try while you’re here.  
• Lobster Bisque at any seafood restaurant on Duval Street – Comfort in a bowl.  
• Yellowtail Snapper and Lobster Tacos – Because life’s about trying everything.  

Grab a copy of our FREE Happy Hour List!

Final Words for Your Lobster Quest  

Exploring Key West through its great food is one of the best ways to spend your time here, and lobster rolls are no exception. From the cozy vibes of Garbo’s Grill to the upscale charm of Latitudes, there’s truly something for everyone’s hungry heart.  

Go forth, my friends, and eat ALL the lobster rolls. You deserve it.