If you think Key West is all seafood and sunsets, think again. Sure, this island excels at stone crab claws and fresh ceviche, but when the pizza cravings hit (and they will), you’ll quickly realize this little slice of paradise has some serious pie game. From wood-fired creations to New York-style slices worthy of a shark-sized appetite, Key West’s pizza joints are here to impress.
And since you’re clearly as obsessed with pizza as I am (it’s why you’re here, right?), we’re breaking down the best pizza places in Key West, from Neapolitan masterpieces to those late-night, “I need carbs NOW” spots. Grab a napkin. It’s about to get cheesy.
What Makes Key West Pizza, Well, Extra?
First, Key West isn’t your average pizza destination. This isn’t some generic Domino’s Pizza situation (no offense, Domino’s, but we’re going for artisan vibes here). Instead, these island spots elevate your classic pie with homemade mozzarella, ancient recipes from Naples and Palermo, and even the occasional seafood topping (hello, lobster pizza with cream sauce).
Whether it’s the wood-fired crust types, the use of extra virgin olive oil, or the ocean breeze giving your dinner a tropical twist, pizza in Key West just hits differently. Okay, so maybe I’m biased. But you’ll get why after biting into a slice topped with spicy salami or green peppers.
The 9 Must-Try Pizza Places in Key West
Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria
For Neapolitan Perfection
Would you pay airfare to Naples just for pizza? Because here’s the good news…you don’t have to. Onlywood’s pizzas are cooked in brick ovens crafted from volcanic materials straight out of Mount Vesuvius. Got goosebumps yet?
What to order: A Margherita Pizza or Spicy Salami Pizza, with their homemade mozzarella on top.
- Location: 613 Duval St
- Hours: 12 PM – 10 PM
- Great for: Romantic date nights or pretending you’re on the Italian coast.
Clemente’s Trolley Pizzeria
For Wood-Fired Pizza and Gluten-Free Options
Craving crispy crusts? Clemente’s wood-fired pizzas don’t disappoint. Bonus points for their gluten-free crust that’s actually good (the gluten-free gals can confirm!).
What to order: Green Peppers & Extra Cheese Pizza.
- Location: 516 Fleming St
- Hours: 12 PM – 11 PM
- Great for: Family pizza nights or feeding the whole crew.
Duetto’s Pizza & Gelato
Pizza on a Budget
Pizza AND gelato? Duetto’s is living proof that carb-loading can be classy. It’s super affordable, features combo deals like their iconic Duetto Pizza & Gelato combo, and takes delivery orders when the rainy day vibes hit. Pro-tip: Check for a delivery charge before calling.
- Location: 540 Greene St
- Hours: 11 AM – 10 PM
- Great for: A quick bite or affordable date night that leaves room for dessert.
Roostica Wood-Fire Pizzeria
For Neapolitan AND Deep Dish
Whether you’re team Neapolitan or team deep dish (why not both?), Roostica has you covered. Toss in some homemade mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil, and nightly specials, and you’ve got yourself a pizza goldmine.
- Location: 5620 MacDonald Ave
- Hours: 11 AM – 10 PM
- Great for: Wine nights with your crew or a post-adventure dinner.
White Street Pizza
New York-Style Slices, No Plane Ticket Needed
Sometimes, you just need a no-frills, NYC-style slice. White Street Pizza nails it with pizza by the slice, perfect for those “I’m starving right now, don’t talk to me until I eat” moments.
- Location: 1109 White St
- Hours: 12 PM – 11 PM
- Great for: Late-night cravings or a solid slice on the go.
Mr. Z’s
Late-Night Pizza Hero
If you’re stumbling out of a Duval Street bar starving at 2 AM, Mr. Z’s is your best friend. Known for their single slice pies, and affordable prices, they’ll save you from some…questionable late-night waffle house choices.
- Location: 501 Southard St
- Hours: 5 PM – 4 AM
- Great for: Post-bar eats or a quick pizza fix after exploring.
Grab our Free Happy Hour list here!
Seaside Café at the Mansion
Lobster Pizza With Ocean Views
This is Key West, so of course there’s lobster on pizza. Seaside Café elevates your standard pie game with an unforgettable Lobster Pizza featuring cream sauce, garlic, and fontina cheese. Oh, and did I mention outdoor seating with ocean views? Chef’s kiss.
- Location: 1400 Duval St
- Hours: 11 AM – 9 PM
- Great for: Fancy pizza nights with Instagram-worthy cocktails.
Moondog Café
For Grilled Pizza & Bakery Goodness
If pizza brunch were a thing, Moondog Café would lead the way. Their grilled pizzas, like the sweet-and-savory Fig & Gorgonzola, pair perfectly with bakery treats and cozy outdoor seating.
- Location: 823 Whitehead St
- Hours: 8 AM – 10 PM
- Great for: A laid-back afternoon or a Hemingway-inspired pizza stop.
Bruschetta Francesca
For Sicilian Authenticity
Run by owners hailing from Palermo, Francesca uses ancient recipes packed with Sicilian flavor. Fresh marinara sauce, homemade mozzarella, and a diverse menu make every bite special.
- Location: 1114 Duval St
- Hours: 5 PM – 10 PM
- Great for: Travel vibes without leaving Key West’s sunshine.
Key West’s Pizza Scene Has It All
From Neapolitan masterpieces to deep-dish indulgences, Key West’s pizza places are just as diverse and vibrant as the island itself. Whether it’s a rainy day delivery order (tip your drivers!) or a late-night slice from Mr. Z’s, there’s a pie for every mood and moment.
