Looking for the freshest seafood in Key West? This guide dives into the top restaurants, iconic dishes, and hidden gems so you can savor every bite.
Key West is seafood heaven on earth. Whether it’s succulent lobster tail, piles of Key West pink shrimp, crispy conch fritters, or tender yellowtail snapper, the island is brimming with flavors that will blow your taste buds away.
Add in the ocean breeze, outdoor dining, and the charm of local fishermen hauling in the freshest catches from the Atlantic Ocean and Gulf of Mexico, and you’ve got the recipe for a memorable dining experience.
But with so many options, where do you start? Don’t worry—we’ve got you covered. Buckle up, foodies and Florida Keys adventurers, because we’re taking you on a tour of the best seafood spots in Key West. From iconic restaurants to hidden gems, we’ve scouted it all.
Iconic Key West Restaurants for Seafood Lovers
Conch Republic Seafood Company
If you’re a seafood lover, the Conch Republic Seafood Company is non-negotiable. Located in the historic seaport, this spot is famous for its Key West pink shrimp and stone crabs. Pair the freshest locally caught seafood with one of their craft beers or specialty cocktails, and you’ve got the perfect place to kick off your Key West culinary tour.
Pro Tip: Don’t miss their happy hour for a fantastic deal on oysters while soaking in the best view Key West has to offer. Add some live music, and you’re golden.
Hogfish Bar & Grill (Stock Island)
Want a taste of authentic Key West? Head over to Stock Island to visit the Hogfish Bar & Grill. Known for the hogfish sandwich, this spot is as local as it gets. Their fresh fish is pulled straight from the local waters by skilled fishermen, ensuring each bite bursts with flavor.
The laid-back setting by the marina makes it a great spot for the entire family. If you’re a first-timer, this is the perfect pairing of exceptional seafood and relaxing vibes.
DJ’s Clam Shack (Duval Street)
Famous for one of the best lobster rolls in the United States, DJ’s Clam Shack is a classic stop on bustling Duval Street. For a casual yet satisfying bite, this is your easy win.
Half Shell Raw Bar
Over in the historic seaport, you’ll find the Half Shell Raw Bar, an emblem of old Florida charm. Their Key lime pie is a must try. Bonus? You can watch local shrimpers unloading the day’s fresh seafood for a true farm-to-table (or rather, sea-to-table) experience.
Blue Heaven
You can’t talk about Key West restaurants without mentioning Blue Heaven. Known for its towering Key lime pie, laid-back outdoor dining under tree canopies, and the iconic roaming roosters, this spot is a vibe. It’s more than seafood; it’s a slice of Key West soul.
Hidden Gems and Local Favorites
Eaton Street Seafood Market
Want to take the local fresh catch home? Eaton Street Seafood Market is your go-to spot for fresh ingredients. Make your pick from a selection of yellowtail snapper, Mahi Mahi, and spiny lobster, or enjoy their prepared dishes. The fish tacos are a fan favorite.
Thirsty Mermaid
For a cozy, refined experience, head to the Thirsty Mermaid. Their perfectly cooked seafood paired with amazing wines makes this a great first stop for seafood connoisseurs.
Little Pearl
If you’re up for a more intimate, surprising culinary adventure, head to Little Pearl. Their tasting menu, which evolves around local fresh catch and seasonal ingredients, is one of Key West’s most coveted experiences. Pro Tip? Book your reservation early!
B.O.’s Fish Wagon
Okay, hear me out. It may not look fancy, but this is the best place for a legendary fish sandwich. Hidden away, B.O.’s Fish Wagon serves up some of the freshest seafood from Key West. Locals and tourists alike rave about their conch fritters too.
Salute! On the Beach
Located on Higgs Beach, Salute! On the Beach serves up light, Italian-inspired seafood dishes with a view. It’s the kind of place where you’ll want to sit for hours, enjoying the ocean breeze while savoring a plate of mahi mahi tacos.
Fine Dining on Fresh Seafood
If you’re looking to elevate your experience, Key West has plenty of upscale, memorable dining experiences to offer.
Louie’s Backyard
The views of the Atlantic Ocean alone are enough reason to visit Louie’s Backyard. Add the beautifully plated, fresh ingredients on the menu, and it’s not hard to see why this spot consistently ranks among the best restaurants on the island. It’s THE spot for date night or any special occasion.
Café Marquesa
Café Marquesa, with its ever-changing menu, promises a dining experience worth dressing up for. Don’t be surprised if lobster tail makes an appearance here, alongside beautifully paired sauces and sides.
A&B Lobster House
Looking for an indulgent lobster tail or buttery filet of fish? A&B Lobster House, located on Front Street, is another must-visit fine dining spot offering both indoor and outdoor seating. Their lobster bisque is a crowd favorite, and their knowledgeable staff provides nothing but friendly service.
Check out more food guides – here.
Unique Experiences and Waterfront Dining
Schooner Wharf
Complete with live music and a wonderful marina view, Schooner Wharf combines great food, drinks, and a laid-back local atmosphere. Their daily happy hour includes some of the freshest seafood at unbeatable prices.
Seaside Café at the Mansion
The lobster pizza at Seaside Café at the Mansion is a local legend. Pair it with a crisp wine while taking in the unobstructed ocean views, and you’ve got perfection on a plate.
Sunset Pier
For unbeatable sunset views, head to Sunset Pier. Their colorful atmosphere matches the bold flavors of their dishes, including locally sourced seafood paired with creative cocktails.
Hurricane Hole (Stock Island)
This off-the-beaten-path hangout is a favorite among locals. You’ll feel completely at ease seated on the dock, enjoying fresh fish dips, colorful plates, and maybe even a jet ski ride after your meal.
Bagatelle
Located on Duval Street, Bagatelle’s outdoor balcony seating makes it easy to enjoy excellent seafood while people-watching in style. Their diverse seafood menu ensures there’s something for everyone.
Save Room for Dessert!
Seafood may be the star of your Key West adventure, but key lime pie is the sweet ending your meal deserves. Nearly every restaurant on this list offers a version of the citrusy, creamy dessert—but if you want the best, Blue Heaven, Half Shell Raw Bar, and Louie’s Backyard top the chart.
Your Perfect Key West Seafood Adventure Awaits
Whether you’re here for an iconic lobster roll, to sip on specialty cocktails by the ocean, or to enjoy the freshest catches from the local waters, Key West will never disappoint. The combination of skilled fishermen, stunning views, and world-class chefs ensures each bite you take is unforgettable.
