Looking for a delicious meal with a side of stunning ocean views? You’re in the right place. Key West, with its blissful beaches and turquoise waters, is not just a paradise for sunseekers but also for foodies. With over 300 bars and restaurants packed into just two miles by four miles of island, there’s no shortage of options. And while we can’t list them all (seriously, we’d be here forever), we’ve selected some incredible waterfront gems that stand out for their menu, ambiance, and that unbeatable Key West vibe.
Grab your sunglasses; we’re dining alfresco.
Sunset Pier
The vibe: Tropical, iconic, and oh-so-Instagrammable.
Sunset Pier isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a Key West landmark. Picture this – colorful chairs, sunshine-lime umbrellas, tropical cocktails in hand, and live music to create the perfect island mood.
Not to mention the sunsets. Oh, the sunsets! Watching the sun dip below the horizon while sipping a mojito feels like a scene straight from a dreamy postcard. Light bites, fresh seafood, and vibrant cocktails make this a must-visit. Bonus points for the incredible photo opportunities.
Pro tip: Head there early to snag a front-row seat to the sunset show. No reservations, but trust us, it’s worth the wait.
Louis’s Backyard
The vibe: Upscale, artistic, and dreamy.
Louis’s Backyard isn’t just a restaurant. It’s an experience. Tucked by the ocean, this spot has been stealing hearts for decades. Think palm-tree-framed views, gentle waves, and a back deck that’s perfect for sipping a glass of wine.
The cuisine? Forget your typical beach bites. Louis’s leans into a Caribbean-inspired, upscale menu with plates like fresh snapper and shrimp linguine. Oh, and there’s Dog Beach right next door, so you might catch a few four-legged swimmers while you dine.
Pro tip: The Afterdeck Bar is your spot if you’re just in it for the view and cocktails. And yes, reservations are highly recommended for the main dining area.
Conch Republic Seafood Company
The vibe: Lively, casual, and beloved by locals.
Ah, Conch Republic, where the seafood is fresh, the vibes are welcoming, and the happy hours are downright legendary. If you’ve never tried Key West Pink shrimp, get ready to have your life changed. Sweet and succulent, they’re an island favorite.
They also serve up Key West Reds (a firmer, lobster-like shrimp variety that’s an off-menu secret), along with tropical cocktails and views of boats bobbing in the marina.
Pro tip: Don’t leave without snagging a BOGO drink token. They don’t expire, like, EVER, so you can stock up for your next visit.
The Schooner Wharf Bar
The vibe: Rustic, old-school Key West charm.
Schooner Wharf is all about the laid-back vibes Key West is known for. There’s plenty of live music and a deck overlooking the water. Order some conch fritters, grab a cold beer, and just soak in the perfect combination of good food, great atmosphere, and amazing views.
Pro tip: Head upstairs for the best water views and an even better breeze.
Latitudes on Sunset Key
The vibe: Exclusive, romantic, and next-level fancy.
For those extra special moments, Latitudes is THE spot. Accessible only by boat (yeah, you’re really living the dream here), this restaurant sits on the pristine Sunset Key. Fine dining meets unbeatable views of the Gulf of Mexico, complete with swaying palm trees and a sea breeze.
From fresh lobster tail to key lime pie that’ll make your heart sing, every dish is carefully crafted for perfection.
Pro tip: Reservations are a MUST. Don’t forget to pack your “dress-to-impress” outfit; there’s a dress code for lunch and dinner.
Hurricane Hole
The vibe: Low-key, local, and utterly charming.
Nestled in Stock Island, just outside the buzz of Key West’s main drag, Hurricane Hole is one of those hidden gems you don’t want to miss. Here, you’re right on the marina, watching kayaks glide by while enjoying fish tacos, “catch of the day” specials, and refreshing drinks.
Pro tip: Want to experience more than just the food? Rent a kayak or paddleboard after your meal and explore the beautiful mangroves nearby.
Half Shell Raw Bar
The vibe: Casual, rustic, and 100% Key West.
Ever wanted to eat at a place where the seafood is so fresh it practically jumps off the boat onto your plate? Half Shell Raw Bar is exactly that. This no-frills spot is all about showcasing the natural flavors of Key West’s bounty. Think oysters, conch, and peel-and-eat shrimp. Grab a beer, enjoy the marina view, and don’t forget the key lime pie for dessert.
Pro tip: Visit during happy hour for incredible raw bar deals.
Southernmost Beach Cafe
The vibe: Funky, laid-back, and beachy.
If breakfast tacos on the beach sound like your kind of morning, Southernmost Beach Cafe is calling your name. It’s nestled near the Southernmost Point and offers beachy bites like Cuban sandwiches, margaritas, and yes, tropical cocktails that are ideal for sipping while your toes are in the sand.
Pro tip: Don’t skip their happy hour – seriously, drink specials and half-off appetizers (think shareable small plates) are an unbeatable combo.
Hogfish Bar and Grill
The vibe: Rustic marina vibes with a side of great conversations.
Detour to Stock Island for a bite at Hogfish Bar and Grill. Known for their signature Hogfish sandwich (a local favorite), this old-school joint is the key to experiencing what truly feels like ‘Old Key West’. Sit by the marina, make friends with locals, and enjoy a cold beer with your fresh-off-the-boat seafood.
Pro tip: Pair your Hogfish sandwich with one of their house cocktails. You won’t regret it.
A&B Lobster House
The vibe: Date-night ready and classic Key West.
This is where you go when you want to dress up a little, enjoy an extensive wine list, and savor steaks and lobster with marina views. Finish the night with a decadent dessert. You’ll leave full, happy, and already planning your next visit.
Pro tip: Ask for an outdoor table for uninterrupted water views.
Where Are You Dining Next?
From whimsical cafes to stylish fine dining, Key West’s waterfront dining scene has it all. Whether you’re looking to sip cocktails as the sun sets, indulge in fresh-off-the-boat seafood, or simply relax amidst the salty breeze, there’s a spot perfect for you.
