There are certain flavors that instantly put me in a Florida Keys state of mind.

Coconut. Pineapple. Key lime. Rum.

Put a few of those together and I am mentally back in Key West, preferably somewhere near the water with absolutely nowhere I need to be.

That is one of the reasons Blue Chair Bay Rum has always felt like such a natural fit around here.

Created by Kenny Chesney and inspired by the island lifestyle that runs through so much of his music, Blue Chair Bay is Caribbean rum with plenty of tropical personality.

And if you have ever stood in front of all those Blue Chair Bay bottles wondering which one you should try, this guide is for you.

We are talking about Blue Chair Bay flavors, rum creams, easy cocktail ideas and, of course, the bottle that practically screams Florida Keys:

What Is Blue Chair Bay Rum?

Blue Chair Bay Rum was created by Kenny Chesney in 2013 around his love of the islands and the laid-back lifestyle that has influenced so much of his music.

The rum itself is made in the Caribbean using sugarcane molasses and natural ingredients.

In 2025, Blue Chair Bay was acquired by Next Century Spirits, with Chesney remaining involved with the brand and becoming a significant owner in the company.

But the heart of the brand still feels very much the same.

Beach days. Boats. Music. Tropical flavors. Slowing life down a little.

Basically, all the things that make an island day pretty hard to beat.

Why Blue Chair Bay Belongs on Fun in Key West

Blue Chair Bay is not a Key West rum.

It is made in the Caribbean.

But if you spend much time around here, you know the Florida Keys are about more than where something was made.

There is an entire island state of mind that comes with them.

Coconut. Banana. Key lime. Rum. Boats. Beaches. Music. Sunsets. And that wonderful moment when you realize you have nowhere else you need to be.

That is where Blue Chair Bay fits.

Those tropical flavors feel completely at home in a Florida Keys cocktail.

And really, that is what I love sharing here.

Sometimes something does not have to be from Key West to take you right back there.

Blue Chair Bay Rum Flavors

One of the things that makes Blue Chair Bay fun is the variety.

There are traditional rums, flavored rums and rich rum creams, so you can go in quite a few directions depending on what kind of drink you are in the mood for.

Some of the Blue Chair Bay flavors you may find include:

• Blue Chair Bay White Rum
• Blue Chair Bay Spiced Rum
• Blue Chair Bay Coconut Rum
• Blue Chair Bay Banana Rum
• Blue Chair Bay Vanilla Rum
• Blue Chair Bay Coconut Spiced Rum
• Blue Chair Bay Key Lime Rum Cream
• Blue Chair Bay Banana Rum Cream
• Blue Chair Bay Pineapple Rum Cream
• Blue Chair Bay Mocha Rum Cream

Blue Chair Bay also releases seasonal and special bottles from time to time, so do not be surprised if you spot something beyond this list.

Now comes the important question.

Which Blue Chair Bay Rum should you try?

Which Blue Chair Bay Rum Should You Buy?

That depends on the kind of drink you like.

If You Love Classic Tropical Drinks

Start with Blue Chair Bay Coconut Rum.

Coconut plays nicely with pineapple, orange, mango and lime, which makes this one of the easiest bottles to experiment with.

If you keep pineapple juice around the house, you are already halfway to a pretty good tropical drink.

If You Like Traditional Rum Cocktails

Try Blue Chair Bay White Rum.

This is the bottle to reach for when you want something closer to a classic rum drink.

Think daiquiris, mojitos and simple citrus-forward cocktails.

If You Like Sweeter Tropical Flavors

Try Blue Chair Bay Banana Rum.

It brings in banana along with caramel, vanilla, toasted coconut and island spice notes.

Banana can be a really fun flavor to play with because it works well with pineapple, coconut and creamy drinks.

If Dessert Cocktails Are Your Thing

Head toward the Blue Chair Bay Rum Creams.

And if you are a Florida Keys person?

Well…

We need to talk about the Key Lime Rum Cream.

Blue Chair Bay Key Lime Rum Cream

Of all the Blue Chair Bay flavors, this may be the one that feels most at home on Fun in Key West.

Blue Chair Bay Key Lime Rum Cream is basically Key lime pie’s cocktail-loving cousin.

The first fresh Key lime notes bring in that tart citrus flavor you expect.

Then you get the creamy texture and sweetness.

And the finish?

Graham cracker crust.

Yes.

Graham cracker crust in a glass.

The tasting notes also include creamy meringue sweetness along with hints of cinnamon, almond and amaretto.

And because this is a true rum cream, it contains real cream.

If you love Key lime pie, you can probably see where this is going.

The combination of tart lime, cream and that graham cracker-style finish gives this one a flavor that immediately feels connected to the Florida Keys.

You can pour it over ice.

Use it in dessert cocktails.

Blend it into a frozen drink.

Or start experimenting with your own Key lime creations.

Personally, this is the bottle that feels like it deserves a sunset and a beach chair.

What Does Blue Chair Bay Key Lime Rum Cream Taste Like?

If you are wondering whether this tastes more like lime or more like cream, the answer is really both.

You get fresh Key lime notes first, followed by a richer, creamy middle and a sweeter finish.

The graham cracker notes are what really pull the whole Key lime pie idea together.

It is sweet, but that tart Key lime flavor helps keep it from feeling one-dimensional.

This is definitely a good choice if you enjoy dessert-style drinks or creamy tropical cocktails.

How Do You Drink Blue Chair Bay Key Lime Rum Cream?

You can make this as simple or elaborate as you want.

A few easy options:

• Pour it over ice
• Serve it chilled
• Add it to coffee
• Blend it into a frozen cocktail
• Pair it with coconut rum
• Use it in a Key lime pie-inspired cocktail
• Add a graham cracker rim for a dessert drink

Honestly, I think one of the best ways to try it the first time is simply over ice.

That lets you actually taste the Key lime, cream and graham cracker flavors before you start adding anything else.

Then start experimenting.

Easy Blue Chair Bay Rum Recipes

This is where we get to have a little fun.

You do not need fifteen ingredients, a smoke machine and a mixology degree to make a great island-style cocktail.

Sometimes simple is better.

Banana Fizz

Light, easy and refreshing.

You will need:

• 2 ounces Blue Chair Bay Banana Rum
• 1 ounce pineapple juice
• Club soda
• Ice

Fill a glass with ice.

Add the Banana Rum and pineapple juice.

Top with club soda and give it a quick stir.

Simple.

Coconut Pineapple Cooler

If coconut and pineapple do not make you think vacation, I am not sure what will.

You will need:

• 1½ ounces Blue Chair Bay Coconut Rum
• 2 ounces pineapple juice
• Splash of orange juice
• Club soda
• Ice

Pour the Coconut Rum, pineapple juice and orange juice over ice.

Give everything a stir.

Finish with a splash of club soda.

Key Lime Pie on the Rocks

This one could not be easier.

You will need:

• 2 ounces Blue Chair Bay Key Lime Rum Cream
• Ice
• Graham cracker crumbs for the rim, optional

If you want the full Key lime pie experience, rim your glass with graham cracker crumbs.

Add ice.

Pour in the Key Lime Rum Cream.

That is it.

Sometimes you should leave well enough alone.

Barrel Roll

This combination reminds me of a grown-up root beer float.

You will need:

• 2 ounces Blue Chair Bay Vanilla Rum
• Root beer
• Ice

Pour the Vanilla Rum over ice.

Top with root beer.

Simple and surprisingly good.

Coconut Pineapple Cooler

If coconut and pineapple do not make you think vacation, I am not sure what will.

You will need:

• 1½ ounces Blue Chair Bay Coconut Rum
• 2 ounces pineapple juice
• Splash of orange juice
• Club soda
• Ice

Pour the Coconut Rum, pineapple juice and orange juice over ice.

Give everything a stir.

Finish with a splash of club soda.

Key Lime Pie on the Rocks

This one could not be easier.

You will need:

• 2 ounces Blue Chair Bay Key Lime Rum Cream
• Ice
• Graham cracker crumbs for the rim, optional

If you want the full Key lime pie experience, rim your glass with graham cracker crumbs.

Add ice.

Pour in the Key Lime Rum Cream.

That is it.

Sometimes you should leave well enough alone.

Barrel Roll

This combination reminds me of a grown-up root beer float.

You will need:

• 2 ounces Blue Chair Bay Vanilla Rum
• Root beer
• Ice

Pour the Vanilla Rum over ice.

Top with root beer.

Simple and surprisingly good.

What Is the Difference Between Blue Chair Bay Rum and Rum Cream?

This is worth explaining because the bottles can look similar when you are scanning a shelf.

Traditional and flavored Blue Chair Bay rums such as White, Spiced, Coconut, Banana and Vanilla are different from the rum cream products.

The rum creams contain dairy.

That gives them a richer, creamier texture and makes them especially good for frozen drinks, dessert cocktails or simply pouring over ice.

So think about how you plan to use the bottle.

For bright, tropical drinks, I usually lean toward Coconut, White or Banana Rum.

For something richer and more dessert-like?

Bring on the rum cream.

Is Blue Chair Bay Rum Gluten Free?

According to Blue Chair Bay, its rums are gluten free.

The company also notes that several of its traditional and flavored rums are dairy-free, while the rum creams contain dairy.

If you are mixing drinks for a group and dietary restrictions are important, always check the individual bottle and the current information from Blue Chair Bay before serving.

How Strong Is Blue Chair Bay Rum?

The alcohol content varies depending on which bottle you buy.

Traditional rum, flavored rum and rum cream products do not all have the same alcohol content.

That means two Blue Chair Bay bottles sitting next to each other may have very different ABV levels.

The easiest thing to do?

Check the label on the individual bottle.

Where Is Blue Chair Bay Rum Made?

Blue Chair Bay Rum is made in the Caribbean.

The brand’s tropical inspiration comes from the same island lifestyle that helped shape its identity from the beginning.

So while this is not a Key West-distilled rum, the Caribbean flavors and relaxed island feel make it an easy fit for Florida Keys-style cocktails.

Where Can You Find Blue Chair Bay Rum?

Blue Chair Bay has a product locator on its website that can help you search for bottles available near you.

That can be especially helpful if you are looking for a particular flavor.

Not every store carries every bottle.

If you are hunting specifically for Key Lime Rum Cream, Coconut Rum, Banana Rum or one of the specialty flavors, it is worth checking before making a special trip.

Which Blue Chair Bay Rum Is Best for a Florida Keys Cocktail?

This one depends entirely on what you like.

But if I were putting together a little Blue Chair Bay rum bar, here is where I would start.

For tropical cocktails: Coconut Rum

For classic rum drinks: White Rum

For something fun and different: Banana Rum

For dessert cocktails: Key Lime Rum Cream

For the most Florida Keys feeling: Key Lime Rum Cream

That Key lime flavor just makes sense here.

And then start experimenting.

That is half the fun.

Easy Mixers for Blue Chair Bay Rum

You also do not need a complicated recipe every time.

A few mixers worth keeping around include:

• Pineapple juice
• Orange juice
• Grapefruit juice
• Lime juice
• Club soda
• Ginger beer
• Root beer
• Lemon-lime soda
• Cream of coconut
• Coffee

Pick a rum.

Pick a mixer.

Add ice.

Taste.

Adjust.

There is your island cocktail laboratory.

Want more island inspired cocktail recipes? Check out more here.

Blue Chair Bay Rum FAQ

Is Blue Chair Bay Rum made by Kenny Chesney?

Blue Chair Bay was created by Kenny Chesney in 2013. In 2025, the brand was acquired by Next Century Spirits, with Chesney remaining involved and becoming a significant owner in the company.

Is Blue Chair Bay Rum made in Key West?

No.

Blue Chair Bay Rum is made in the Caribbean.

But its tropical flavors and island-inspired story make it a natural fit for Florida Keys-style cocktails.

Does Blue Chair Bay Key Lime Rum Cream contain dairy?

Yes.

It is a rum cream made with real cream.

What does Blue Chair Bay Key Lime Rum Cream taste like?

Expect tart Key lime flavor, creamy sweetness and a finish reminiscent of graham cracker crust.

If you love Key lime pie, this is probably the Blue Chair Bay bottle you should try first.

Can you drink Blue Chair Bay Rum straight?

Absolutely.

Several Blue Chair Bay flavors can be served over ice or chilled.

The rum creams are especially easy to enjoy on their own.

What mixes well with Blue Chair Bay Coconut Rum?

Pineapple juice is an obvious choice, but orange juice, mango, lime, cream of coconut and club soda can all work well too.

What mixes well with Blue Chair Bay Banana Rum?

Try pineapple juice, coconut, vanilla flavors, cola or club soda.

It also works well in frozen tropical drinks.

Your Turn: Which Blue Chair Bay Flavor Wins?

Now I want to hear from you.

What is your favorite Blue Chair Bay Rum flavor?

Are you Team Coconut?

Key Lime?

Banana?

Or is there another bottle I need to add to my rum bar?

And even better…

What drink are you making with it?

Drop your favorite flavor or Blue Chair Bay cocktail in the comments.

I may just have to taste-test a few of your suggestions.

You know.

For research.

Cheers from the islands!

sources – www.bluechairbayrum.com