A Food Lover’s Guide to the Best Spots on the Island
Welcome to Key West, a tiny island paradise with a big personality — and an even bigger appetite. Nestled at the southernmost point of the United States, Key West is a hotspot of flavors, fusions, and fresh seafood that attracts food enthusiasts from around the world. From fresh-caught fish tacos to the best key lime pie, this tropical destination offers culinary delights for every kind of foodie.
Whether you’re here for a quick weekend getaway or a long-overdue vacation, your taste buds are guaranteed to thank you. Key West has over 300 bars and restaurants packed into its 2×4-mile stretch, so no matter what, you’re in for a feast. But with so many delicious food options, where should you start? Don’t worry—I’ve got you covered. Here’s your ultimate guide to the best Key West restaurants, happy hour favorites, and local spots that’ll make your visit unforgettable.
Breakfast in Key West: The Perfect Start to Your Day
1. Cuban Coffee Queen (Original Location on Margaret Street)
Start your morning like a true local at Cuban Coffee Queen, the go-to spot for the café con leche of your dreams. Packed with rich, robust flavor, this South Florida staple is the caffeine kick you need to explore the island. Pair it with a Key Wester breakfast sandwich stuffed with eggs, cheese, and more. And don’t forget to snap a selfie at their famous mural before you leave—it’s a Key West tradition!
2. Blue Heaven
Tucked away in the historic Bahama Village, Blue Heaven is the perfect blend of great food and quirky charm. This iconic Key West restaurant serves breakfast dishes worth drooling over, like their lobster benedict or fluffy french toast. The roosters wandering around the al fresco dining area add to the island vibe, and for good reason—this spot is a local legend. Pair that with a Bloody Mary, and you’re in breakfast heaven.
3. Southernmost Beach Café
Craving ocean views while you eat? The Southernmost Beach Café is the perfect place. With a menu that features everything from classic bacon-and-eggs to fresh seafood dishes like grilled mahi, you’ll fuel up while enjoying postcard-worthy scenery. Plus, it’s a great spot to hydrate from the night before with something off their “hangover cures” menu.
Pro Tip: Late risers can swing by Harpoon Harry’s for diner vibes and diner plates, but keep in mind, they’re cash-only!
Snack Time and Key West Midday Bites
4. Garbo’s Grill
Nothing says Key West like a meal from this beloved food truck. Featured on “Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives,” Garbo’s Grill is home to mouthwatering tacos and lobster rolls. It’s parked right next to Hank’s Hair of the Dog bar, so you can wash down your meal with a refreshing white peach sangria.
5. Bo’s Fish Wagon
This beaten-path gem may not look fancy, but it’s bursting with character. Grab a killer fish sandwich or some Key West pinks from this casual shack that embodies the island’s charm. It’s one of those places where the food is as iconic as the vibe.
6. Eaton Street Seafood Market
At Eaton Street Seafood Market, you’ll find ultra-fresh seafood sourced straight from local waters. Want to cook? Grab some stone crab claws or freshly caught grouper fillets to whip up at your rental. Not in the cooking mood? No problem—their prepared lobster rolls or crispy fish tacos are perfection.
7. Amigos Tortilla Bar
Situated on Greene Street, Amigos Tortilla Bar is perfect for quick bites and people-watching. Feast on custom-made tacos and nachos—served with freshly pressed tortillas—and sip on a margarita while you watch Duval Street come alive.
Seafood and Dinner Spots You’ll Love
8. Half Shell Raw Bar
If slurping oysters overlooking the historic seaport sounds like a good idea, this place is a must-visit. The Half Shell Raw Bar serves up fresh seafood with no fuss—just a cool, casual dockside vibe. The Key West pink shrimp, fish dip, and stone crabs are all local favorites.
9. El Siboney
Fans of Cuban food will fall head-over-heels for this Old Town gem. Dig into comforting classics like ropa vieja, roast pork, and the best Cuban sandwich in town. It’s the definition of a great place to enjoy a feast that feels like home.
10. Hogfish Bar & Grill
Looking for something off the beaten path? Head to Stock Island to visit this hidden gem. The Hogfish Bar & Grill keeps things casual with picnic tables and old-school Key West vibes. Try their famous hogfish sandwich—a local favorite that will change how you think about seafood.
11. Hot Tin Roof
Celebrating something special—or just in the mood for fine dining? Make reservations at Hot Tin Roof. With small plates that specialize in fresh Key West seafood, this romantic dining room treats you to a world-class culinary experience featuring dishes like yellowtail snapper and spiny lobster.
Sweet Treats and Desserts in Key West
12. Better Than Sex Dessert Bar
If your sweet tooth calls for a dessert-focused adventure, head to Better Than Sex. Indulge in decadent treats paired with chocolate-dipped glasses of wine. It’s a one-of-a-kind experience unlike any other in Key West.
13. Key Lime Pie Crawl
No trip to Key West is complete without sampling the best key lime pie. From Blue Heaven’s buttery version to Kermit’s iconic offering, there’s no shortage of places claiming the title of the best dessert menu around.
14. Flaming Buoy Filet Co.
Known for its bold flavors, this tiny island hotspot serves up desserts that are a sweet conclusion to any meal.
Drinks, Happy Hours, and Live Music
15. Conch Republic Seafood Company
Looking for the best happy hour? Look no further than the Conch Republic Seafood Company, a favorite haunt for locals and visitors alike. Enjoy the buy-one-get-one drink coin deal while snacking on fresh-caught local seafood.
16. Sunset Celebration
Head to Mallory Square for a sunset celebration you won’t forget. Food trucks and pop-ups serve conch fritters, hot dogs, and even a creative take on key lime aioli dishes. It’s a great spot to sip tropical cocktails, watch the sun dip below the horizon, and cheer on street performers.
Discover Your Key West Flavor
Food in Key West isn’t just sustenance—it’s an adventure. From quirky local restaurants and food trucks with bold flavors to upscale dining rooms with breathtaking views, the island offers everything a foodie could dream of and more. Whether you’re downing fresh fish tacos straight from the local fishermen or sipping café con leche from Cuban Coffee Queen, your taste buds are in for a vacation of their own.
Planning your next trip? Be sure to make room for all these favorites on your Key West food itinerary—and explore even more hidden gems along the way.
