When you think about Key West, it’s easy to picture sun-drenched beaches, the endless allure of Duval Street, and iconic spots like the Ernest Hemingway Home. But if you’re craving a more authentic slice of this quirky paradise, you’re probably wondering, “Where do the locals go in Key West?”

Spoiler alert! Locals in Key West enjoy many of the same places as visitors. Why? Because some spots are just that good. That said, a few hidden gems and off-the-beaten-path spots remain tucked away from the usual tourist route. Read on to discover how to experience Key West like a local.

Monroe County Sheriff’s Animal Farm

This is not your average petting zoo. Open on the second and fourth Sunday of every month, the Monroe County Sheriff’s Animal Farm is a family favorite among locals. Home to more than 150 animals, including lemurs, alpacas, and a giant tortoise, the farm feels like a charming oasis where families and animal lovers can unplug. Bonus points? The farm’s rich history began with rescuing ducks in the 1990s.

If you’re visiting with little ones, this is a great place for an afternoon outing to create unforgettable memories.

Arts, Theater, and Cinematic Escapes

Looking to soak in the cultural vibes of Key West? Locals flock to these spots for arts, entertainment, and live creativity.

• Red Barn Theatre – A historic venue with plays for all tastes. This gem has been operating since the ‘80s and brings everything from comedies to moving dramas to life.
• Waterfront Playhouse – Nestled on Wall Street, this historic landmark is known for its incredible live performances.
• Tropic Cinema – Forget blockbuster chain theaters. Tropic Cinema is where locals go for first-run movies, nostalgic genres, and even Movies Under the Stars. With intimate seating and killer popcorn, this is a great way to spend a relaxing night out.

Dining Like a Local in Key West

When it comes to food, locals know where to find good eats without the long tourist lines. Here are a few local hotspots to try while you’re in town.

Off-The-Radar Restaurants

• El Siboney on Catherine Street – Enjoy authentic Cuban cuisine, like café con leche and conch fritters, in a true mom-and-pop environment.
• Hogfish Bar & Grill on Stock Island – Located just outside the main touristy zone, this hidden gem serves some of the freshest seafood, including its namesake Hogfish sandwich.
• Garbos Grill – A cozy food truck vibe with island-famous tacos and burritos. Locals love their quick service and fresh menu.

Chic and Cozy Spots

• Little Pearl – With a romantic atmosphere and the freshest seafood options, it’s one of the best restaurants in Key West for a refined yet laid-back dining experience.
• Vinos on Duval – Offering a curated wine selection and cozy vibe at the quieter end of Duval Street, it’s perfect for locals looking to unwind.
• The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. – A local favorite for its creative menu items like lobster macaroni and cheese.

Key West Adventures and Experiences Locals Adore

Water Fun that Hits the Right Spots

The Florida Keys are synonymous with water activities, and locals know how to enjoy them in their backyard paradise. From the white sands of Sandbars to the crystal-clear waters of the Dry Tortugas, here’s how locals live it up on and in the water.

• Sandbars – Many locals head out to the Gulf of Mexico for some of the best spots for relaxation and social connection at Key West’s stunning Sandbars. Captain Howie’s Make It So Charters is a great way to experience a sandbar like a local.
• Lazy Dog Adventures – For a peaceful paddle, locals turn to kayaking or paddleboarding with Lazy Dog Adventures. Their eco-tours glide along serene mangroves, offering a great way to connect with nature.
• Fishing Excursions – Whether it’s deep-sea fishing on the Atlantic Ocean or backcountry fishing in the Gulf, Key West is a haven for anglers.

Local Nightlife and Music Hotspots

No Key West guide is complete without mentioning the vibrant nightlife. Whether you’re after live music, cocktails, or a bit of everything, locals swear by these great spots.

• Green Parrot Bar – Iconic and unpretentious, this classic bar features the best live music and a cool crowd. Locals love the intimate vibe and legendary “soundcheck.”
• Chart Room Bar – Known for its retro charm, free popcorn, and complimentary hot dogs, this bar on William Street has been a favorite local hangout since 1967.

Off-the-Beaten-Path Attractions

Rediscover Key West’s Unseen Side

• Key West Historic Seaport – Stroll along a section of Old Town where rich heritage meets modern charm. Locals love the laid-back vibe and scenic views lined with sailboats.
• Key West Lighthouse – Escape the touristy mainstays and get unbeatable panoramic views of the island.
• Audubon House & Tropical Gardens – Learn about the island’s history while admiring beautiful gardens and interactive exhibits featuring the works of ornithologist John James Audubon.

Curious for Dessert? Try These Local Sweets

Key Lime Pie lovers, rejoice. Locals say the best Key Lime Pie in Key West isn’t confined to tourist traps. Great spots like Blue Heaven dish out tangy, creamy slices. And for a sweet spin, the pie-on-a-stick at Kermit’s is always a crowd favorite.

How Locals Live the Island Life Daily

Key West locals run errands, commute by bike or scooter, and deal with parking headaches like the rest of us. However, they balance their routine with community gatherings and unique experiences that make life here so magical.

Whether it’s enjoying a glass of wine during happy hour, tasting Jamaican jerk chicken on Petronia Street, or admiring coral reefs on a snorkel trip, life in the Lower Keys is infused with unforgettable moments and stunning scenery.

Your Key to a Local’s Key West

When visitors ask, “Where do the locals go in Key West?” the answer is simple. Locals experience Key West like you would—but with an insider’s eye. It’s all about exploring beyond the surface, finding balance between buzzing tourist spots and hidden corners, and relishing every good day spent under palm trees.