Where Locals Eat in Key West

Key West may only be five-ish square miles, but it’s packed with rich history, unique culture, mouthwatering meals, and quirky charm. Whether you’re visiting for the first time or you’re dreaming of your next trip to the southernmost city, there’s one question on every foodie’s mind – where do the locals eat?

While Key West is famous for its lively tourist vibes (hello, Duval Street and Mallory Square), some of the best food isn’t always where the tourists flock. From quaint spots serving fresh fish straight from local waters to food trucks dishing out conch fritters, here’s your insider guide to the best Key West restaurants where locals love to dine.

The Food Spots That Locals Keep Secret

Garbo’s Grill for Food Truck Goodness

If you’re looking for melt-in-your-mouth fish tacos and Korean BBQ from a food truck with a cult following, Garbo’s Grill is the place to go. Tucked away near Hank’s Hair of the Dog Saloon, this gem combines laid-back Key West vibes with standout flavors. Bonus? Hank’s offers live entertainment and delicious white peach sangria to pair with your grub. Perfect for a relaxed afternoon.

Local Tip: Garbo’s has been featured on Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives, but its new location means fewer tourists… maybe. Bring your dog (it’s pet-friendly!) and enjoy a chilled-out vibe with locals.

El Siboney for Cuban Food Cravings

Craving Cuban food? El Siboney in Old Town is a go-to for locals who need hearty portions and flavorful Cuban dishes without breaking the bank. Their Cuban sandwich and grouper dishes are simply unforgettable.

Local Tip: Order the conch chowder … trust us, it’s a good idea. Oh, and don’t skip dessert! Their flan is loved by locals and tourists alike.

Eaton Street for Fresh Catch

Seafood lovers, Eaton Street Seafood Market is calling your name. This is where Key West locals grab grouper sandwiches, pink shrimp, and fresh seafood to-go. Whether you’re picking up dinner to cook or craving a fresh fish sandwich, this market always delivers.

Local Tip: Try their conch ceviche or shrimp salad for a taste of the local waters. You’ll want seconds, guaranteed.

Blue Heaven for Breakfast Hangovers

The vibe at Blue Heaven is as Key West as it gets. Roosters roaming around, sandy floors, and live music set the stage for indulgent breakfast dishes like their famous lobster Benedict and mile-high Key lime pie.

Local Tip: Beat the crowd by heading there early. Their Key lime pie is legendary and easily one of the best key lime pies in Florida.

The Cuban Coffee Queen

What’s a Key West morning without Cuban coffee? Cuban Coffee Queen is a local favorite for good reason. Their café con leche is incredible, and their Cuban breakfast sandwiches hit the spot before any island adventure.

Local Tip: Snap a photo by their famous “Greetings from Key West” mural while you sip.

Want Elevated Dining? Locals Have Favorites for That, Too

Louie’s Backyard for Waterfront Views

If fine dining with a view is your thing, try Louie’s Backyard. This iconic spot offers al fresco dining right by the water, making it a perfect place for romantic dinners and sunsets.

Local Tip: Make a reservation and definitely try their Cracked Conch with Hot Pepper Jelly & Wasabi Cream. It’s a crowd-pleaser among locals.

First Flight Island Restaurant and Brewery

Known as the southernmost microbrewery, First Flight combines history and great food. The outdoor patio is a great spot for good times, craft beers, and American classics with a Key West twist.

Local Tip: Locals rave about the entire menu, but the beer sampler is a big hit.

A and B Lobster House for Fine Dining

For fresh seafood with a touch of luxury, A and B Lobster House reigns supreme. Known for their lobster bisque and spiny lobster, this spot is a must if you’re celebrating a special occasion.

Local Tip: Pair your meal with their waterfront seating for an unforgettable evening.

Where Locals Go for a Drink and Live Music

Sloppy Joe’s for Iconic Key West Vibes

You can’t leave Key West without stepping into the historic Sloppy Joe’s. Known for its Ernest Hemingway connection, this is where you’ll find locals indulging in great food, drinks, and live music.

Local Tip: Don’t just order a drink; grab conch fritters or a sloppy joe while soaking up the live entertainment.

Schooner Wharf Bar

Locals flock to this beloved waterfront bar for its live music and unbeatable happy hour. Open early, you can enjoy breakfast, lunch, or dinner while mingling with regulars just off the boats.

Local Tip: Their tuna nachos are a hidden gem worth trying every time you visit.

Hog’s Breath Saloon

Famous for its tagline, “Hog’s Breath is Better Than No Breath at All,” this spot is a magnet for music lovers and good times. Local musicians and even celebrities pop in for a jam session.

Local Tip: Check out who’s playing and pair it with their tropical drinks for a night to remember.

Hidden Gems for Sweet Treats

Kermit’s Key Lime Shoppe

Don’t leave Key West without indulging in Kermit’s famous chocolate-dipped Key lime pie on a stick. It’s the ultimate vacation treat, loved by locals and visitors alike.

Local Tip: Have a slice with their Key lime honey-glazed coffee for a unique pairing.

Old Town Bakery

If you’re strolling along Elizabeth Street, stop by Old Town Bakery for heavenly pastries. Their ginger snap crust Key lime pie and rich brownies are local favorites that never disappoint.

Local Tip: Pair it with an iced coffee for the perfect afternoon pick-me-up.

Create Your Own Key West Foodie Adventure

Key West’s dining scene is as colorful as its sunsets and as diverse as its residents. Whether you’re looking to dig into fresh seafood, Cuban cuisine, or quirky conch house eats, this southernmost city is a foodie paradise.

Grab our Free Happy Hour Guide – Sign up here

Next time you’re in the Conch Republic, venture off the beaten path, ask locals for their secret go-to spots, and make your meals as memorable as the stunning views and vibrant culture around you.

Feeling adventurous? Why not book a walking food tour and get insider tips from locals while exploring the best places to eat? It’s a good choice to experience Key West through their eyes (and taste buds).