Key West is a slice of paradise for seafood fans. Fresh ocean air, great views of the Gulf of Mexico, and a plate full of delectable local seafood? It doesn’t get better than this. And when it comes to crab, Key West punches well above its weight. Whether you’re after sweet Florida stone crab claws, golden-brown crab cakes, or even soft-shell crab, this charming island city has it all.
Not sure where to start? Don’t worry! I’ve scoped out the best places to satisfy your crab cravings. From quaint markets to upscale dining spots, Key West serves up crab dishes that’ll make your taste buds do a happy dance. Also, fun fact for seafood enthusiasts out there, stone crab season runs from October 15th to May 1st every year. All the more reason to visit during that time!
Grab your bib, seafood lover, because we’re diving in!
Why Key West is a Crab Paradise
The Florida Keys are celebrated for their renewable resources like Florida stone crab, spiny lobster, and a variety of local fish. Thanks to its favorable environment supported by vibrant seagrass beds and the hard ocean floor, the area boasts healthy local crab populations. Local fishermen use sustainable practices, ensuring new claws (don’t worry, the stone crabs’ ability to regrow helps maintain populations) are always fresh and abundant.
And the taste? Chef’s kiss. Whether you’re enjoying black-tipped claws with tangy key lime mustard sauce or digging into soft-shell crab sandwiches, Key West’s seafood delivers culinary creations that are nothing short of top-notch.
Need recommendations? I’ve got the perfect best spots for you to explore!
The Best Crab Dishes and Restaurants in Key West
1. Hot Tin Roof
- Why You’ll Love It: This spot offers fancy oceanfront dining with stunning Gulf of Mexico views. It’s a great place to sit back, relax, and savor every bite. Date night, anyone?
- What to Order: Try their Crab Cake with Bacon and Corn Sauce. The sweet crab meat melds perfectly with smoky bacon and a creamy corn sauce. Yes, it’s rich, and yes, it’s worth every bite.
2. Eaton Street Seafood Market
- Why You’ll Love It: This is the perfect spot for fresh crabs and laid-back vibes. You can purchase daily catches of stone crab or grab a bite right there. Bonus points for their ready-to-eat menu that includes picnic-perfect options.
- What to Order: Their Crab Cake Sandwich is piled high with fresh crab, making it an easy win for lunchtime. Want to cook your own? Grab some fresh seafood and head back to your hotel’s kitchen for a DIY dining experience.
3. Cafe Marquesa
- Why You’ll Love It: Tucked next to the Marquesa Hotel, this charming restaurant offers a cozy dining experience you won’t forget.
- What to Order: Their She-Crab Soup is rich, creamy perfection. Add their tropical-inspired Crab Cake topped with a fruity sauce for a fun island twist.
4. Loggerheads
- Why You’ll Love It: Imagine this. You’re sitting beachside, cold beer in hand, munching on a crab cake sandwich while your toes are buried in the sand. Absolute bliss.
- What to Order: Their Crab Cake Sandwich with Caribbean Sauce hits the spot. Oh, and did I mention they serve every sandwich with a cookie? That’s right. Cookie lovers, rejoice.
5. The Thirsty Mermaid
- Why You’ll Love It: This hidden gem has a funky atmosphere paired with a stellar beer and wine selection. Great for smaller bites and unique creations.
- What to Order: Go adventurous with their Soft-Shell Crab Sandwich. The entire crab (shell and all!) is perfectly crispy and an experience you won’t forget.
6La Te Da Restaurant on Duval
- Why You’ll Love It: For a perfect blend of elegance and Key West’s lively charm, head to this iconic spot on Duval Street. The vibrant atmosphere and historic setting make it an unforgettable dining experience.
- What to Order: Their Crab Cake Salad with Champagne Vinaigrette. It’s fancy-sounding but totally approachable, making this an elegant midday treat.
7. Seven Fish
- Why You’ll Love It: Head over to this lowkey spot (with a new spacious location!) for a friendly open-air atmosphere and plate after plate of deliciousness.
- What to Order: Their Crab Cake with Ginger Garlic Sauce adds a zingy, spicy twist to the classic crab dish. Be sure to pair it with one of their local cocktails!
8. Conch Republic Seafood Company
- Why You’ll Love It: Located in the historic seaport, this spot not only delivers Key West’s freshest seafood but also serves it up with live music and good food.
- What to Order: Their Stone Crab Claws with Traditional Dip. Pair it with the best key lime pie in town for the ultimate Key West finale!
9. Half Shell Raw Bar
- Why You’ll Love It: This waterfront treasure is the best place to enjoy raw oysters or Key West shrimp alongside your crab favorites. The friendly open-air atmosphere makes it a great hangout spot.
- What to Order: Grab a pound of fresh stone crab claws and drench them in their signature key lime mustard sauce.
10. The Stoned Crab at Ibis Bay Beach Resort
- Why You’ll Love It: Nestled at Ibis Bay, this place serves up some of the best stone crab claws from its own fleet of fishing boats, straight to your plate.
- What to Order: The Stoned Cold Chiller, which highlights the diversity of Key West’s seafood as well as some Dungeness crab.
Pro Tip for First-Timers
If it’s your first time in Key West, try planning your visit during stone crab season (October 15th to May 1st) to enjoy the legendary Florida stone crab at its freshest. These delectable claws (often served chilled with a tangy mustard sauce) are a must-try for every seafood enthusiast.
And yes, snapping up some fresh stone crab claws to-go from Keys Fisheries or Key Largo Fisheries is always a quick way to keep the magic alive post-vacation.
Check out our Fun in Key West Book club – sign up here
The Sweet Reward of Key West’s Crab Scene
From casual markets to upscale eateries, and even beachfront sands, Key West’s crab offerings cater to every seafood lover. Whether it’s sweet crab meat, a chilled cocktail, or new claws straight off a fishing boat, there’s something magical about crab in the Florida Keys. It’s a culinary creation you’ll crave long after you leave.
Next time you visit, be sure to explore everything Key West restaurants have to offer, one crab dish at a time. Oh, and don’t forget to top it off with the best key lime pie Key West is famous for!
