Key West, Florida. A tropical paradise known for its amazing views, vibrant culture, and of course, mouthwatering cuisine. And when it comes to food, there’s one dish that stands out amongst the rest – fresh fish tacos.

Now, before we dive into the best places to get the best tacos, let’s first break down what makes a fish taco truly exceptional.  First and foremost, the star of the show – the fish. Key West and the Florida Keys boast some of the freshest seafood in all of Florida, so it’s no surprise that their fish tacos are top-notch. From flaky white fish to succulent shrimp and everything in between, you can’t go wrong with any type of seafood in your taco.

But let’s not forget about the other crucial elements – the toppings and sauce. A good fish taco needs just the right amount of crunch, so a generous serving of fresh cabbage or slaw is a must. And for that extra burst of flavor, a drizzle of tangy, creamy sauce is essential.

Now that we have the basics covered, let’s get into the top spots to indulge in some of Key West’s best fish tacos.  I think you will notice a theme… they are all Hidden Gems!  But, seriously, did your favorite place make the list?

Garbo’s Grill

Let’s talk about Garbo’s Grill, the hidden gem located on Caroline Street at Hank’s Hair of the Dog Saloon. Trust me, you don’t want to miss out on their mouthwatering Cayo Fish taco – it’s a flavor explosion in every bite! 

Once you’ve got your taco in hand, find a seat and get ready for a treat. Not only does Garbo’s offer delicious food, but it’s a great spot for live music that’ll have you tapping your feet and grooving along. This is always one of my first stops when I am on the island.

And if you’re in the mood for a refreshing cocktail, head into Hank’s and try their White Peach Sangria – it’s an absolute winner in my book! So, come on down to Garbo’s Grill, grab some grub, enjoy the tunes, and let the good times roll!

Hogfish Bar & Grill

Alright, my friend, let’s dive into the world of Hogfish Bar & Grill, located on Stock Island. I gotta tell you, this place is a hidden gem that’ll transport you back to the golden days of Key West charm. 

Picture this: you’re sitting there, minding your own business, and suddenly you catch a glimpse of the boats unloading the freshest catch of the day. It’s like a seafood parade right before your eyes.

But let’s get down to the real reason you should be here: the hogfish taco. Trust me when I say that it’s a taste bud extravaganza that’ll leave you craving more. Once you’ve had a bite, I can guarantee you’ll be hooked and plotting your return to this little slice of paradise. 

So, don’t wait any longer – head over to Hogfish Bar & Grill and embark on a culinary adventure of fresh seafood and friendly staff that’ll make you a lifelong fan. See you there, taco lover!

In the mood for Conch Fritters?  Check out our list of the best places in Key West for Conch Fritters

Southernmost Beach Cafe

If you’re on the lookout for a taste bud-tantalizing experience that combines the best of Caribbean flavors with a good ol’ American twist, then look no further than Southernmost Beach Cafe. Brace yourself for a culinary journey that will have your taste buds doing the limbo! 

Picture this: you’re lounging on the beach, feeling the sand between your toes, when suddenly your stomach starts growling in agreement. It’s time to answer the call of those tantalizing fish tacos.

But hold up, what’s a taco without a refreshing beverage to wash it down? That’s where Southernmost Beach Cafe comes to the rescue with their housemade margaritas and frozen tropical drinks. Trust me, folks, these drinks are like a vacation for your taste buds.

And speaking of margaritas, let me introduce you to my personal favorite: the skinny margarita. It’s like a ray of sunshine in a glass – light, refreshing, and the perfect companion to those mouthwatering fish tacos. 

Stoned Crab

I’ve got one heck of a gem for you: the Stoned Crab, nestled right next to the beautiful Ibis Bay Beach Resort. Get ready to have your taste buds rocked by some seriously epic fish tacos and good food.

Now, let me spill the secret ingredient that sets the Stoned Crab apart from the rest: their two private fishing boats. Yep, you heard it right. These bad boys go out daily and reel in the freshest, local catches straight from the ocean. Talk about quality you can taste.

So, when you sink your teeth into those fish tacos at the Stoned Crab, you can bet your fins that they’re going to blow your mind. Flavorful, tender, and bursting with that ocean goodness, these tacos are like a party in your mouth.

​Grab our FREE Key West Happy Hour list

Kaya Island Eats

Have you ever craved a culinary experience that transports you straight to the sunny shores of the Pacific and the Caribbean? Well, look no further than Kaya Island Eats, located right on lively Duval Street. Prepare your taste buds for a wild ride.

Now, let’s get down to business because I’m about to introduce you to their claim to fame: the Killer Fish Tacos. These bad boys are no joke! Imagine sinking your teeth into lightly blackened fish, perfectly complemented by a fresh and tangy mango and pineapple salsa. And as if that wasn’t enough, they take it up another notch with a zesty Key Lime cilantro sauce. It’s a flavor explosion that will leave your taste buds singing a tropical tune.

Moondog Cafe

Picture this: you’re strolling across from the legendary Hemingway House, soaking in the Key West charm, when suddenly your stomach starts rumbling like a catamaran caught in a storm. Fear not, my friends, for salvation awaits you at Moondog Cafe.

Let’s dive right into the star of the show: their fish tacos. Brace yourselves, because these babies are no ordinary tacos. We’re talking about local mahi mahi, perfectly cooked to flaky perfection, nestled in a warm tortilla. But wait, there’s more! These tacos come dressed to impress with avocado, sour cream, queso fresco chimichurri, and pico de Gallo. It’s a flavor fiesta that’ll make your taste buds do the salsa.

Now, here’s the cherry on top (or should I say the muffin on the side): Moondog Cafe has outdoor seating! So, imagine indulging in those mouthwatering fish tacos while basking in the warm Key West sunshine. It’s a feast for the senses, my friends.

But hold up, we can’t forget about their bakery. Oh boy, oh boy! Whether you’re craving a breakfast muffin to start your day off right or a sinful dessert to top off your fish taco extravaganza, Moondog Cafe has got you covered. They’ll satisfy even the most discerning sweet tooth.

Fisherman’s Cafe

Have I got a hidden treasure for you in the heart of the historic seaport: Fisherman’s Cafe. Prepare to have your taste buds transported back in time to the authentic flavors of Old Key West.

Now, let’s dive right into the star of the show: their made-to-order fish tacos. Brace yourselves, folks, because these aren’t your average tacos. Fisherman’s Cafe knows how to reel in the flavor with their fresh catches of the day. Picture this: tender, flaky fish, perfectly seasoned and nestled in a warm tortilla. It’s a taste bud tango that’ll make you want to do a conga line.

But here’s the kicker, my friends: the authentic flavors of Old Key West. With every bite, you’ll feel like you’re right there in the golden era of this vibrant coastal town. The mix of spices, herbs, and secret seasonings will transport you to a time when life was simpler and the seafood was unbeatable.

And let’s not forget the ambiance! Fisherman’s Cafe is nestled in the historic seaport, surrounded by the sights and sounds of the ocean. So, imagine savoring those mouthwatering fish tacos while feeling the salty breeze on your face and listening to the seagulls serenade you. It’s an experience that’ll make your taste buds do a happy dance.

In the mood for more tacos?  Check out our list of the Best Places in Key West for Tacos (other than fish of course!)

Lagerheads

Have I got a hidden gem for you that’ll make your taste buds and beach-loving heart do a happy dance: Lagerheads. Get ready to experience fish tacos like no other.

Now, let’s talk about the star of the show: their fish tacos with lettuce instead of slaw. For those of us who prefer a crisp crunch over a saucy slaw, this is a game-changer. It’s a wonderful change of pace that’ll have you saying, “Where have you been all my life?”

But hold on tight, because there’s more to this taco fiesta. When you order these delectable fish tacos at Lagerheads, they don’t stop there. Oh no, they take it up a notch by serving them with fresh fruit and a cookie. It’s a combination that’ll have your taste buds doing a happy salsa.

Now, let’s talk about the setting. Picture this: you’re sitting on Simonton Beach, toes in the sand, with a picturesque view of the sparkling ocean. Add to that the sweet sounds of live music filling the air, and you’ve got yourself a recipe for pure bliss. It’s the kind of place that makes you feel like every day is a vacation.

And let’s not forget the cherry (or should I say lime) on top: enjoying all of this with a margarita in hand. Sip, savor, and let the worries of the world wash away with each delicious sip. It’s the perfect companion to a beachside feast.

Amigos Tortilla bar

Have I got a spot for you that’ll make your taste buds sing and your eyes twinkle with delight: Amigos Tortilla Bar. Get ready for a fiesta of flavors, great food and a front-row seat to all the action in Old Town.

First things first, let’s talk about the outdoor seating. It’s like having your own private balcony overlooking the happenings of the bustling streets. You can sit back, relax, and enjoy your tacos while soaking in the sights and sounds of Old Town. It’s a great place for some quality people-watching, my friends.

Now, let’s get to the star of the show: the square taco. Why square, you ask? Well, it’s simple math, really. More sides equal more space for toppings! And let me tell you, Amigos Tortilla Bar knows how to load up those bad boys with all the fixings you could dream of. It’s a flavor explosion that’ll have you doing a salsa dance in your seat.  Don’t forget to pair with their black beans and rice.

But hold on tight, because we’re not done yet. Add one of their legendary margaritas into the mix, and you’ve got yourself a party.

Stock Rock Cafe

I’ve got some exciting news for you about one of the newest hotspots in town: Stock Rock Cafe. Prepare to embark on a waterfront tiki experience like no other at Cow Key Marina.

First things first, let’s talk about the setting. Stock Rock Cafe offers a waterfront tiki experience that’ll make you feel like you’re on a permanent vacation.

Now, let’s get to the good stuff: the craft beer selection. Brace yourselves, because it’s MASSIVE. From hoppy IPAs to smooth stouts, they’ve got something to satisfy every beer aficionado’s palate. You can explore a world of flavors while enjoying the laid-back island vibes. Cheers to that!

But wait, there’s more! Keep your eyes peeled because you never know when a friendly manatee might make an appearance. Imagine sipping your beer and suddenly spotting these gentle giants gracefully gliding through the water. It’s like having a real-life National Geographic moment right in front of your eyes. Talk about a beer-drinking bonus.

Old Town Mexican Cafe

Hold on to your sombreros because I’ve got something spicy and refreshing to share with you: Old Town Mexican Cafe. Located right on the vibrant Duval Street, this place is anything but your typical TexMex joint. Get ready for a flavor fiesta inspired by the culinary wonders of Santa Fe and authentic Mexican cuisine.

First things first, let’s talk about the chef’s inspiration. They’ve taken all the vibrant flavors and bold spices from the New Mexican foods of Santa Fe and blended them seamlessly with the authenticity of Mexican cuisine. It’s like a flavor explosion that’ll have your taste buds doing the salsa!  Their flavors really shine in their Baja fish tacos.  

But wait, there’s more! Old Town Mexican Cafe knows how to keep the party going with their daily frozen drink specials. Whether it’s a tangy margarita, a fruity daiquiri, or a tropical piña colada, they’ve got a frozen concoction to satisfy every craving. It’s like a vacation in a glass, my friends.

DJ’s Clam Shack

I’ve got a spot on Duval Street that’ll make your taste buds do a happy dance: DJ’s Clam Shack. Brace yourselves for a culinary journey that fuses the best of Northern and Southern seafare into one heck of a seafood extravaganza!

Picture this: tender New England clams meeting the bold flavors of Southern cuisine. It’s like a seafood love story that’ll have you swooning with every bite. DJ’s Clam Shack has mastered the art of creating amazing dishes that showcase the best of both worlds. It’s no wonder they caught the attention of Guy Fieri and were featured on Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives. These folks know their seafood, my friends.  So they may be known for their lobster rolls, but they also make yummy fish tacos and shrimp tacos.

Now, let’s talk about the seating situation because we can’t forget about that. DJ’s Clam Shack not only serves up mouthwatering dishes but also offers seating in the back. So, you can enjoy your seafood feast in a cozy and relaxed atmosphere. It’s like having your own little oasis where you can dive into a sea of flavors.

Kim’s Kuban

I’ve got some insider scoop for you about a hidden gem in Key West: Kim’s Kuban. Located on North Roosevelt, this is the spot where the locals flock to satisfy their cravings for mouthwatering Cuban and Mexican cuisine. Get ready to embark on a taste bud extravaganza!

Let’s talk about their fish tacos because they are the stars of the show. Imagine perfectly grilled fish, nestled in a warm tortilla and topped with vibrant flavors that’ll make your taste buds do the cha-cha. From tangy lime to fresh cilantro, every bite is a fiesta of amazing flavors. These fish tacos are like a flavor party in your mouth, and you’re invited.

What Makes a Great Taco?

Alright, taco lovers, buckle up for a flavor-packed adventure! We’re about to dive into what makes a great taco and trust me, it’s a journey you won’t want to miss. First things first, let’s talk about the star of the show: fresh, locally caught fish. Picture this – tender flakes of fish that practically melt in your mouth with each bite. It’s like a little taste of the ocean right on your plate. So, when it comes to tacos, always remember, fresh is best!

Now, let’s taco ’bout the tortilla. A great taco needs a tortilla that can hold all the deliciousness without falling apart. Whether it’s a soft and fluffy flour tortilla or a crispy corn tortilla, the foundation of a great taco starts right there. It’s like a cozy little blanket that wraps up all those amazing flavors.

But wait, we can’t forget about the toppings and sauce! They’re like the supporting actors that take the taco to a whole new level. Think vibrant cilantro, zesty onions, and a squeeze of tangy lime. These fresh toppings add a burst of freshness and crunch to every bite. And let’s not forget about the sauce – a dollop of creamy guacamole or a drizzle of fiery hot sauce can elevate the flavors to taco heaven.

So go ahead, plan a trip to Key West, and embark on the ultimate fish taco adventure. Who knows, you may just find your new favorite spot for some amazing food. And don’t forget to pair it with a refreshing margarita, cold beer, and a slice of Key Lime pie – after all, that’s what vacation is all about.