Let’s be honest: finding a happy hour in Key West is about as difficult as finding a rooster crossing the street. They are everywhere. But finding a happy hour that has the trifecta of great prices, killer water views, and a side of fascinating history? That is a little harder to come by.
If you’ve been visiting the island for years, you might be scratching your head thinking, “Wait, didn’t The Boathouse used to be over by Alonzo’s?” You aren’t losing your mind (well, maybe a little, it is Key West after all). It moved!
Whether you’re a long-time regular or a newbie looking for the best peel-and-eat shrimp on the rock, here is everything you need to know about settling in at The Boathouse.
Where in the World is The Boathouse?
First things first—let’s clear up the confusion. If you walk over to Front Street expecting to find The Boathouse, you’re going to be disappointed (that spot is now the White Tarpon).
The Boathouse has relocated to the Historic Seaport, taking over the spot where the old Turtle Kraals used to be. If you’ve been coming here since the days of disposable cameras, you might remember going there for the turtle races. It’s right in the heart of the action, giving you those classic harbor vibes where you can watch the boats come in while you nurse a cold drink.
Happy Hour: The Main Event
Okay, let’s get to the important stuff. The Boathouse happy hour runs every single day from 4:00 PM to 6:30 PM. And unlike some “happy hours” that just knock a dollar off a bud light, this one is actually worth writing home about.
We’re talking half-price on their small plate appetizers. Yes, half off. They also run some solid drink specials on beer, craft brews, wines, and specialty cocktails.
What to Order
Here is your game plan for the menu:
- Peel and Eat Shrimp: You can get a half-pound or a full pound. At half price, this is arguably one of the best bargains on the island.
- Conch Fritters: A staple. If you leave Key West without eating these, did you really even visit?
- Fresh Catch Bites: Crispy, fresh, and perfect for sharing.
Pro tip: The “tapas style” approach is the way to go here. Order three or four small plates, split them with your table, and boom—you’ve got a full dinner for a fraction of the price.
The Mandatory Dessert
I have a personal rule: You must try Key Lime Pie wherever you go, just to see who does it best. I haven’t met a slice I didn’t like yet, and The Boathouse is no exception. Save room for it.
Drinking on Top of History
Here is the cool part that most people miss while they are staring at their margaritas. When you are sitting at The Boathouse or walking along that boardwalk, you are standing on a massive piece of Key West history.
This site used to be an actual “turtle kraal.” Back in the 1800s, before refrigeration was a thing, these were shallow water corrals used to hold live green sea turtles. Key West was once an international hub for turtle meat and soup (I know, sad to think about now!), shipping it all over the world.
Thankfully, over-harvesting led to conservation laws in 1971 that shut the industry down. Now, we just admire the turtles in the wild. But as you look out at the water, it’s wild to imagine that this exact spot was once the center of a global trade.
The Vibe and Views
This isn’t a stuffy, white-tablecloth kind of joint. The Boathouse has that quintessential, casual waterfront energy. It doesn’t feel like a flashy redo of the old Turtle Kraals; it feels lived-in and authentic.
Just a heads up: Because the secret is out, it can get busy during happy hour. Plan your timing accordingly!
Once you’re done stuffing your face with shrimp, take a wander down the pier. You can check out the relics from the turtle industry museum, watch the sunset sails loading up their passengers, and snap some envy-inducing photos for your Instagram.
An Authentic Slice of Key West
So, who is this spot for? If you want to save a few bucks, love fresh seafood, and want a view that screams “vacation,” this is your spot. It feels authentically Key West—a little historic, a little busy, and delicious.
Go check it out, grab a cold one, and let me know if their Key Lime Pie makes your top 5 list!
