From the moment your first sip of bourbon touches your lips to the rich flavors that linger after, there’s something truly magical about exploring the world of bourbons. For whiskey connoisseurs and newbies alike, understanding how to order bourbon properly can set the tone for the ultimate experience, whether you’re sitting at your favorite bar or curating your own home bar. If terms like “neat pour” or “small batch bourbon” confuse you, don’t worry—you’re in good company.
Today, we’re here to break it all down for you. Whether you’re enjoying Kentucky bourbon, like Maker’s Mark or Wild Turkey, or sampling a premium bottle of Pappy Van Winkle, this guide will walk you through the best way to order bourbon confidently. You’ll also gain insight into bourbon’s history, different flavor profiles, and fun bourbon facts. Now grab a glass of whiskey and settle in. By the end, you’ll be a bourbon-ordering pro!
What Makes Bourbon Special?
Let’s begin with a little bourbon 101. Bourbon is a type of American whiskey—but not all whiskeys are bourbons (stay with me here). To be labeled bourbon, a spirit has to meet specific criteria; these rules, declared by Congress in 1964, make bourbon America’s native spirit.
- It’s made in the United States (most of it comes from Kentucky, thanks to the state’s fertile soil and limestone water).
- The mash bill must be at least 51% corn. This is what gives bourbon its signature sweet flavor.
- It’s aged in charred oak barrels. These barrels can only be used once for bourbon, giving an unmistakable caramel, vanilla, and oak flavor.
- No additives are allowed. Bourbon is as pure as a good time can get, with no added colors or flavorings.
Quick Fact Alert! Did you know that neat means bourbon served at room temperature with nothing added? It’s a great way to savor all those distinct tasting notes of fruit, spice, oak, and even burnt sugar.
Now that you know the “what,” let’s get to the fun part—how to order your glass of bourbon like a seasoned pro.
The Best Ways to Order Bourbon
Different ways of enjoying bourbon depend on your taste buds and chosen atmosphere (we’ll get to that later!). Here’s a breakdown of the most common ways to order a glass of bourbon at your favorite bar or liquor store:
1. Neat
The purist’s choice. A neat pour is simply bourbon served at room temperature in a rocks glass or, for the fancy whiskey connoisseurs out there, a Glencairn glass. This method is perfect for someone looking to focus purely on the spirit’s unique flavor profile.
2. On the Rocks
Prefer your bourbon cooler? Ordering it “on the rocks” means it’s served over ice cubes. The ice slowly melts, diluting the bourbon slightly and mellowing the flavors. Pro tip for your first time trying bourbon on the rocks? Ask for a single, large ice cube to chill your drink without watering it down too quickly.
3. With Water
Adding drops of water to your bourbon might seem strange, but trust us—it’s a good idea. A splash of water opens up the flavors and aromas of bourbon, especially for higher-proof bottles.
4. Cocktails
Not ready for bourbon straight up? Cocktails are a fun, approachable way to enjoy your favorite bourbon. Classics like the Old Fashioned, Mint Julep, or Manhattan mingle bourbon with just the right ingredients for a perfectly balanced drink. Pro tip? Use small batch bourbon like Woodford Reserve for an elevated cocktail.
5. Try It as a Flight
Can’t decide which type of bourbon to try? Many bars offer bourbon flights—a selection of three or more pours, often showcasing different brands or styles. It’s a good way to explore various flavor profiles from rye whiskey-forward bourbons to wheat-heavy variants like Maker’s Mark.
Choosing Your Bourbon
Beginner Bourbons
- Maker’s Mark: Smooth, sweet, and perfect for bourbon beginners.
- Buffalo Trace: Affordable and well-rounded, it’s a customer favorite.
- Evan Williams: A great way to get started without breaking the bank.
For the Bourbon Buff
- Knob Creek: Slightly stronger flavors and bold fruit notes.
- Eagle Rare: Aged for 10 years, offering depth and a touch of romance for whiskey lovers.
- Blanton’s Single Barrel Bourbon: Known for its collectible bottles and premium feel.
Feeling Adventurous?
- High Rye Bourbon: Go for Bulleit Bourbon for a spicier kick.
- Cask Strength Bourbon: Jump into a bold territory with Elijah Craig Barrel Proof.
Pair Your Bourbon with the Atmosphere
Where you drink bourbon can be just as important as what bourbon you drink. Here’s how to match your order with the vibe.
At Your Local Dive Bar
Stick to the classics like Wild Turkey or Jim Beam, neat or with ginger ale. It’s a good thing to keep it casual.
Upscale Cocktail Bars
These spots are all about creativity—order a signature cocktail made with premium whiskey like Angel’s Envy for its hints of port wine barrels.
Hosting a Bourbon Night at Home
Stock your home bar with diverse options like small batch bourbons, Tennessee whiskeys, and a wine glass or Glencairn glass to really set the mood.
Bourbon Trivia for Good Times
- Bourbon got its name from Bourbon County, Kentucky, a historical center for distillation.
- A single barrel bourbon like Blanton’s means all the liquid comes from one specific barrel, ensuring a unique flavor from other bottles.
- Want to buy bourbon online? Most online stores now offer monthly clubs where you can explore different types of bourbons every month.
Bourbon Adventures in Key West
If you’re lucky enough to be in Key West (or planning your next adventure there), here are some top spots to enjoy bourbon in paradise.
- General Horseplay: Perfect for old-fashioned lovers, they even offer cocktail classes!
- The Roost: Try their Old Forester Old Fashioned Wednesdays special for a midweek bourbon celebration.
- Old Town Tavern: Whiskey Wednesdays mean 50% off whiskeys and bourbons.
Check out our other Key West bar suggestions!
Raise Your Glencairn Glass High!
At the end of the day, bourbon drinking isn’t just about the liquor—it’s about the experience, the company, and savoring life’s good times. Whether you’re trying your first sip of Buffalo Trace, swirling a neat pour of Pappy Van Winkle, or exploring the endless world of bourbon cocktails, there’s no wrong answer (as long as you enjoy it).
Now, the only thing left to decide is how you’re ordering your next glass of bourbon. Planning to explore from home? Check out our online store for exclusive bottles that will light up your home bar—and don’t forget to share your favorite bourbon moments with us in the comments below.
Cheers to great bourbon and even better memories!